I am thinking 4 options for me:
1) Get a new set of matte charcoal 18x8 Tenzo R wheels:

2) Get another set of RPF1s but they will be used silver ones in the same size for ~$150 cheaper than the new Tenzos
3) Sell the new, non-fitting wheels but keep the new max summer tires, put them on the RPF1s and then sell the Falken all-seasons
4) Don't get anything and just sell the new, non-fitting wheels and tires so that you put the money back in the bank.