Page 1 of 1

Street View mobiles are wiretapping on wheels

Posted: Tue Jul 05, 2011 5:55 pm
by zaxrex
Judge says Google is guilty of invasion of privacy by intercepting and recording open WiFi data packets.
Apparently doesn't have digital radio in his car.
A federal judge has found that Google can be held liable for damages for secretly intercepting data on open Wi-Fi routers. The ruling is a serious legal setback for the search giant over activity it has engaged in across the United States for years.

That decision, the first of its kind, was handed down late Wednesday by a Silicon Valley federal judge presiding over nearly a dozen combined lawsuits seeking damages from Google for eavesdropping on open Wi-Fi networks from its Street View mapping cars. The vehicles, which rolled through neighborhoods across the country, were equipped with Wi-Fi–sniffing hardware to record the names and MAC addresses of routers to improve Google location-specific services. But the cars also secretly gathered snippets of Americans’ data.

Google, in seeking a dismissal, claimed it is was not illegal to intercept data from unencrypted, or non-password-protected Wi-Fi networks. Google said open Wi-Fi networks are akin to “radio communications” like AM/FM radio, citizens’ band and police and fire bands, and are “readily accessible” to the general public — a position rejected by Ware.
So that means that anyone with a baby monitor can be held liable for wiretapping by picking up older wireless home phone conversations? I hardly call that sophisticated technology.

Re: Street View mobiles are wiretapping on wheels

Posted: Tue Jul 05, 2011 11:27 pm
by complacent
this is bonkers... completely bonkers.

in an increasingly dependent digital world, this is akin to listening to people talking in a public park and calling it eavesdropping.

madness. i has a sad.

Re: Street View mobiles are wiretapping on wheels

Posted: Wed Jul 06, 2011 9:29 am
by Sabre
The biggest problem we face is that the legal system (aka, the judges) do not understand technology and make rulings like this.

Re: Street View mobiles are wiretapping on wheels

Posted: Wed Jul 06, 2011 10:36 am
by zaxrex
Sabre wrote:The biggest problem we face is that the legal system (aka, the judges) do not understand technology and make rulings like this.
Nonsense.
If that were true then this title would mean nothing; Silicon Valley federal judge










Oh. Right.

Re: Street View mobiles are wiretapping on wheels

Posted: Wed Jul 06, 2011 12:05 pm
by Raven
Wifi isn't "like" FM radio, it's exactly the same! Fucking stupid people! :x

Re: Street View mobiles are wiretapping on wheels

Posted: Wed Jul 06, 2011 6:34 pm
by zaxrex
Raven wrote:Wifi isn't "like" FM radio, it's exactly the same! Fucking stupid people! :x
C'mon now, if that were true, then I should be able to listen to NPR by plugging headphones into the WAP router. But then that would be a stupid people thing to do.